Changes

}}'''"Gave Up"''' is the sixth track on the 1992 ''[[Broken]]'' EP. It continues the EP's musical themes of being loud and aggressive, as well as showing themes of nihilism, self-loathing, and chaos in the lyrics.

*Production: [[Flood]], [[Trent Reznor]]

Just like the ''And All That Could Have Been'' version, the ''Beside You In Time'' is performed very closely to the album version. The only difference is the keyboard solo by [[Alessandro Cortini]], which sounds different than [[Charlie Clouser]]'s in the previous DVD (which was nearly identical to the album version).

[[Image:Gaveup2.jpg|thumbnail|Screen shot of Gave Up music video directed by Jon Reiss]]

Throw it away

[[Category:NIN Songs]][[Category:Music Videos]]