Changes

*[[Ralf Dietel]] (2005) (Replaced by Aaron North at the last minute. Never , never played a live show with them.)*[[Robin Finck]] (1994–1995, 1999–2000, 2008–09 )

*[[Rich Fownes]] (2008, studio ) (Studio only, never made it to the road , replaced by Meldal-Johnsen)

*[[Justin Meldal-Johnsen]] (2008–09 )

*[[Brian Liesegang]] (Replacement for a few nights when Mars was out drunk. Helped , helped in the studio during on ''Broken '' when Woolley was gone., featured in one of the music videos for "[[Gave Up]]")

*[[Gary Talpas]] (1989) (First live keyboardist on for a few shows of the first Pretty Hate Machine tour, (only a few shows). He was replaced by Rushe on the subsequent tour. Also, also the original NIN art director.*[[Keith Hillebrandt]] (1998-2001) Studio member, song writing credits, was planned to be part of a multiple-keyboardist setup for the live band Trent originally planned. The Fragile took a different route sonically though, even after planning this and Keith didnt play live. However he did replace Clouser during the CRC sessions when the band played live in 2000. Was listed as full band member on the Afraid Of Americans remix along with Reznor, Lohner, Clouser and, Dave "Rave" Ogilvie.*[[Dave "Rave" Ogilvie]] (1997-1999) See Keith above. 

*[[Sean BeavenBeavan]] (Backup vocals from mixing console for the Self Destruct and Pretty Hate Machine tours)*[[Martin Atkins]] Drums(1991–19921991-1992)(Studio-only drummer, studio only. Featured featured in music video for [[Head Like A Hole (song)|Head Like A Hole]])*[[Wes Borland]] Guitar (Replaced Auditioned for guitar player in 2004, eventually replaced by Aaron North from further auditions, 2004)*[[Atticus Ross]] (Creative partner, mixer and programmer for NIN since ''With Teeth '' era. Was , was guest keyboardist for several of the final Wave Goodbye tour shows)*[[Tim Neimi]] (Additional synth design on ''Pretty Hate Machine'')*[[Keith Hillebrandt]] (1998-2001) (Studio member, songwriting credits, was planned to be part of a multiple-keyboardist setup for the live band Trent originally planned but ''The Fragile'' took a different route sonically and Keith didn't play live, replaced Clouser during the CRC sessions, was listed as full band member on the "I'm Afraid Of Americans" remix along with Reznor, Lohner, Clouser and Dave "Rave" Ogilvie)*[[Dave “Rave” Ogilvie]] (1997-1999) (Was listed as full band member on the "I'm Afraid Of Americans" remix along with Reznor, Lohner, Clouser and Keith Hillebrandt)