1,016
edits
Changes
m
it makes no sense that part of Vig's remix of Last would appear on a Gave Up remix
Guest remixers include [[Butch Vig]], [[J. G. Thirlwell]] of Foetus, [[Peter Christopherson]] of Coil, and members of the live band at the time, which included [[Chris Vrenna]] and [[James Woolley]].
The official release had one contribution by Butch Vig, which was the end portion of "[[Gave Up|Throw This Away]]". Vig had originally remixed the song "[[Last]]", but it was cut from the final version of the EP. Trent said that Vig basically did what he always does with any song: he made it rock. However, Vig has stated in interviews that his remix of "[[Last]]" was not included simply because "Trent didn't like it". Therefore only part of Vig's mix appears at the end of "[[Gave UpLast|Throw this Away]]". The original mix appeared on the internet as an 8-bit mono 11khz file, NIN_LAST.AIFF, available by ftp from CYBERDEN.COM in 1993. It disappeared from the site quite some time ago, but can still be found on p2p networks. It is also hosted on the unofficial NIN ftp server (accessable [http://www.symphonyofnoise.com/nails/ here]).
This remix EP employs some rather unorthodox mixing techniques to give the listener an intentional sense of confusion on initial (and sometimes subsequent) listenings. On the opening "[[Gave Up]]" remix, the song picks up with a frantic rhythmic jumbling of Trent's vocals directly referencing the lyrics ("smashed myself to pieces"). This would seem to involve chopping up each syllable of the chorus vocals running forward and reverse (normally as PCM files) and use a sampler to re-sequence them together in manic fashion. Like many avant garde industrial music acts before, this release helped pioneer the notion of the [[remix]] as an artform, far removed from just commercial "milking" of an existing product. Remix artist [[John Balance]] (of Coil) expressed his dislike of choruses in the song and decided to take it in another direction.