The initial line-up of the band included McMahon on vocals, John Guardico on guitar, Dennis DeVito on bass and Brian Dempsey on drums. The band released a number of singles in between the late 70s and early 80s, before going on hiatus until 1988, when the ''Communique'' EP was released.
The band reformed in 1988 with new member Kevin McMahon on vocals, Tom Lash on bass, Dave Zima on drums, Rick Christyson on guitar, and Trent Reznoron keyboards. [https://cplorg.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/p16014coll5/id/37894/rec/4] Reznor left in 1989 and the band was dissolved in 1990. This was followed by McMahon's next project, [[Prick]]. Prick was signed to [[Nothing Records]], had its first album partially produced by Reznor, and was a support act for the [[Dissonance]] tour.
In 2004, McMahon revived the Lucky Pierre name (though he was the sole member) to release the first full length album, ''ThinKing''.