Difference between revisions of "Talk:A Warm Place"
LOWER CASE g (talk | contribs) (A WARM PLACE) |
|||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
GIVES ME HOPE THAT IN THE END WHEN I'M COLD...I CAN LOOK BACK AND REPLAY THAT PART OF MY LIVE AND HAVE AT LEAST SOME SENCE OF WARMTH WITH IN...: | GIVES ME HOPE THAT IN THE END WHEN I'M COLD...I CAN LOOK BACK AND REPLAY THAT PART OF MY LIVE AND HAVE AT LEAST SOME SENCE OF WARMTH WITH IN...: | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The Downward Spiral Motif == | ||
| + | |||
| + | it sais 'A melody in "A Warm Place" is an inverted version of that used in "Closer" and "The Downward Spiral".' | ||
| + | |||
| + | i would like to see an explanation, like on the Piggy page, because this seems to be a wrong statement, or i have the wrong idea of what is ment with the term 'inverted'. | ||
| + | |||
| + | is it the melody that kicks in at 0:59? or the chord progression? eitherway, when i listen to the song reversed, i don't hear anything that sounds like the TDS motif. nothing that would suggest Trent on purpose made the melody this way, other than making it ascending; in contrast with the TDS motif which is descending, but melody-wise as well as rythm-wise all parts are so different that i don't understand why it's labeled as a different version of the TDS motif; how someone ever came up with this "fact". | ||
Revision as of 23:32, 10 March 2008
I've got to say, whenever I hear this song I feel lonely. -crazyninfan
When is this on closure?? Armac 22:30, 14 May 2007 (PDT)
- It's used in a montage at the end of Tape 1, and in the opening sequence of Tape 2.--Leo3375 06:41, 15 May 2007 (PDT)
wasn't the version that was done with added vocals from Stella Soleil a legitimate, officially commissioned remix/mashup/version? shouldn't it be noted? Jgrizzy89 00:42, 28 May 2007 (PDT)
A WARM PLACE
GIVES ME HOPE THAT IN THE END WHEN I'M COLD...I CAN LOOK BACK AND REPLAY THAT PART OF MY LIVE AND HAVE AT LEAST SOME SENCE OF WARMTH WITH IN...:
The Downward Spiral Motif
it sais 'A melody in "A Warm Place" is an inverted version of that used in "Closer" and "The Downward Spiral".'
i would like to see an explanation, like on the Piggy page, because this seems to be a wrong statement, or i have the wrong idea of what is ment with the term 'inverted'.
is it the melody that kicks in at 0:59? or the chord progression? eitherway, when i listen to the song reversed, i don't hear anything that sounds like the TDS motif. nothing that would suggest Trent on purpose made the melody this way, other than making it ascending; in contrast with the TDS motif which is descending, but melody-wise as well as rythm-wise all parts are so different that i don't understand why it's labeled as a different version of the TDS motif; how someone ever came up with this "fact".