The Trilogy

Halo 29: Not The Actual Events

Halo 31: Add Violence

Halo 32: Bad Witch

Not The Actual Events, Add Violence and Bad Witch form a trilogy of related albums, respectively released in 2016, 2017 and 2018. The tours I Can't Seem To Wake Up 2017 and Cold And Black And Infinite Tour took place to support it. This period marks the inclusion of Atticus Ross as an official member of NIN, as well as a member of the live band during the tours.

Tracklist

Not The Actual Events

1. "Branches/Bones" – 1:46
2. "Dear World," – 4:06
3. "She's Gone Away" – 6:00
4. "The Idea Of You" – 3:27
5. "Burning Bright (Field On Fire)" – 5:50

Add Violence

1. "Less Than" – 3:30
2. "The Lovers" – 4:09
3. "This Isn't The Place" – 4:44
4. "Not Anymore" – 3:06
5. "The Background World" – 11:44

Bad Witch

1. "Shit Mirror" – 3:06
2. "Ahead Of Ourselves" – 3:30
3. "Play The Goddamned Part" – 4:51
4. "God Break Down The Door" – 4:14
5. "I'm Not From This World" – 6:41
6. "Over And Out" – 7:49

Concept

Links to other NIN material

The Downward Spiral

Side B of the Not The Actual Events vinyl features 3 additional, unlisted tracks from The Downward Spiral in reverse: "Hurt", "The Downward Spiral" and "Reptile".

In the physical component for Not The Actual Events, the lyrics of "She's Gone Away" are superimposed over a copy of page 14 from the Deluxe Edition booklet of The Downward Spiral, and lyrics embedded in the Apple Music release include extra, unsung words directly referencing "Reptile".

Additional lyrics for "Less Than" are printed on the physical component of Add Violence, and they seem to reference "March Of The Pigs" by using the line "doesn't it make you feel better".

The Fragile / Still

Additional lyrics for "This Isn't The Place", printed on the physical component of Add Violence, are a direct quote from "The Great Below", with the line "I can still feel you, even so far away". Trent stated that "This Isn't The Place" is about David Bowie during a concert. It can be speculated that this line relates to mourning in both case.

An alternate front cover for Not The Actual Events is a re-used Still cover art.

With Teeth / Bleedthrough

Lyrics from the track "The Background World" feature a reference to the Bleedthrough concept, in the line "Is always bleeding through".

Additional lyrics for "The Lovers" printed on the physical component of Add Violence feature the word "godlike", possibly referencing "The Life You Didn't Lead". In an episode of the Song Exploder podcast[1], Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross explained that the song is about an alternate reality that explores what might have happened if Reznor had never left his old home of New Orleans and had never gotten clean and sober. It began as a sort of poem he had written in order to explore what he calls the "seduction of addiction" and stated that "it was me allowing myself permission to examine a period of my life that I had consciously chose not to think about very much, then immerse myself in it in a kinda 'What if the path I'm currently on wasn't really the right one, and I just went hard-left the other way?".

Year Zero

Add Violence is in part a continuation of the Year Zero story and its ARG, with elements appearing on the front cover and the back cover of the album ("SIMULATION ON", "PRESENCE", "2022", etc), in the music video for "This Isn't The Place" (Appearance of a "Cedocore" box), and on the physical component. They are all linked together with multiple variations of the panel, mentions referencing the concept of The Trilogy, the physical component appearing itself in the music video, etc.

Artworks

Not The Actual Events

• 

  Alternate digital artwork - Origin: Embedded in first 2016 digital files

• 

  Vinyl cover art

• 

  Physical component

• 

  Physical component package

• 

  Hidden lyrics example 1

• 

  Hidden lyrics example 2

• 

  Lyric card depicting "Reptile" superimposition

Add Violence

• 

  Physical component

• 

  Add Violence back cover

Bad Witch

• 

  Alternate Cover

• 

  Bad Witch back cover